レビュー要約

• 読者の反応は、物語の舞台と語りの巧みさに集まっている。信仰と危うさが交差する旅として面白がる声がある一方、会話中心の運びを好みが分かれる点として挙げる声もある。

• 批評的には、この作品は自伝性の強い、やや散漫だが魅力的な小説として読まれている。キリスト教圏とユダヤ的背景のあいだを往復する感覚が、作品の複雑な魅力を支えている。

レビュー

• I first read this book many years ago and was delighted to read it again. I enjoyed it very much and found it had not become dated but carried its weight well as a period piece. It renewed in me a desire to return to more Muriel Spark novels and I am busy doing so. I am disappointed to discover that "The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie" does not seem to be available as a Kindle book.. If I am correct, I hope that Amazon will rectify this situation. Mind you I am 94 and not very good on the computer so it may be that I am wrong in my Assumption. I recommend Muriel Spark both for new readers and as a good "second time round" for those who have not read her books b efore.

• This book wasn't overly compelling but had some nice moments. I liked it for the clipped, English humor but found the plot uninspired and somewhat pointless. The drivers seem arbitrary and forced. When looking for a well-stitched story, one hopes for invisible seams. Unfortunately, while visible here, they were also noteworthy for binding together the mismatched. The whole story depends on an uncharacteristic manic episode experienced by Freddy Hamilton, the main protagonist. A frame for the story gradually emerges during the course of the narrative, revealing events from some point in the future. This is not Marlow sitting on a verandah smoking, but seems instead like quick conversations in passing at social events. Even from what little we learn about these future characters, they seem unbothered as they look back. Leaving out the incongruous motives for the various characters' actions, the writing is fine. Spark's descriptions are great, and she has a knack for dialogue. She also renders the socio-religious dynamic of Barbara Vaughn's upbringing well. Finally, on their own, her characters can be quite interesting. So, while I "liked" the book within the confines of the rating system, I wouldn't recommend it as one to immediately seek out.

• Muriel Spark is a gem. Although I don't love all of her work, this is one that I do love. Still timely, although the gate is now not a crossing, and unfortunately things have probably gotten worse, the story resonates with the problems of the region just as it did when written. Perhaps a bit too much for some readers, this is not a light weight travel novel, nor a sentimental novel of love and barriers to love. It is a novel of religious feeling, political intrigue, and personal choices that was absorbing back when I first read it years ago, and last month when I bought and read the Kindle edition. I highly recommend it for thoughtful readers.

• Great price and book as good as new. Excellent service would certainly deal with them again. I will be a returning customer.

• Here we have an unconvincing plot too pointless to sustain a novel. Spark wants to show off her knowledge of biblical locales in the Holy Land. The reader wants more story and more love interest. It’s not a satisfying read. It has won some plaudits but one can’t see why.

購入リンク